IRAN WAR - STUCK BEHIND THE TIGER'S TAIL?
The Big Bang
The
Iran war started with a bang, in fact, a series of big bangs. Unlike the big
bang that is said to have started the universe, the bangs from the 30-odd bombs
dropped over multiple locations in Tehran were meant to create a new world order.
The precision-guided air-launched ballistic missiles that first climbed into
their sub-orbital trajectory in the “near space” and darted down at extremely
high speeds onto the secure compound where Ayatollah Khamenei lived. It was Operation
Epic Fury, unveiled. Immediately thereafter, Prime Minister Benjamin Nethenyahu
and President Trump declared that the ‘evil regime’ has been decapitated.
This
was on 28 Feb 2026.
The
world waited to see the high-speed evolution where the Iranians took to the
streets in multitudes, overturned the regime, chased the mullahs out, and
installed someone Uncle Sam, the benevolent and righteous, liked. After all,
the Iranians under a repressive regime deserved redemption. All sorts of experts
declared that Iran would fold up in a matter of a few days, if not hours.
Nothing of that sort happened. Epic fury is still about sound and fury,
with no significant move forward in evolution.
Today
is 21 Mar 2026.
Endlessly
Furious
It has
been twenty-one days into the war, after a superpower and an aspiring
superpower unleashed their ‘epic fury’ and rained bombs on an already severely
degraded adversary. Asymmetrical warfare is holding down the
mighty. Everyone knows what Iran has lost in the war, but no one knows
anything about the other side. It is illegal to publish it, I am told.
But
there is enough spectacle. One can see the most powerful man on earth, the
President of America, claiming that he is winning the war that he had already
won, not just once but twice. In the first week of March 2026, he destroyed Iran’s
nuclear assets, which he had already obliterated in June 2025. And, he is still trying
to destroy their nuclear capabilities. You can also hear him shout out to his
allies, asking for help to win the war, which he already won. He then tells them he
does not need any more help because they refuse to give it to him. Yesterday, he
even called them cowards for not joining the fight that he had already won. The
war continues.
He is
mad at the Iranians, who refuse to be freed from an evil regime that doesn't
exist anymore. He is not ready to stop the war because he is not happy with the
offer he says Iran has made. Iran refuses to stop the war unless America makes
good the losses. Who on earth can be happy paying reparations?
Operation
Epic Fury has brought America, Israel and the Gulf states into a situation like
the one holding the Tiger’s tail. That is an interesting old Malayalam folk
tale. We will keep it for the end.
Fury To Whose Benefit?
The
war is being fought by one country against two, supported and wished away at
the same time by the others in the Middle East. The war has now come to a stage
of targeting oil production facilities. Israel bombed Iran’s gas fields. America
says it did not know. Iran, in turn, set ablaze Qatar's fields and told everyone
that they did it. Iran set fire to Israel's refinery, too. Everyone is
condemning Iran for retaliating as if it is illegal for a country to retaliate
against aggression. The impact of the war is not confined to the region. The
war is fast spinning out of control and has serious implications for the whole
world.
Who is
benefiting from this war? The natural corollary to the question is, “Who stands
to lose from this war?”
We
will start with those directly involved. We shall consider each player and look
at their gains and losses. We will start with Iran.
After
all, according to America, Iran was the cause of the war.
Iran
Down
and suffering over 20 years of sanctions imposed by America, they had nothing
on the balance sheet other than the means to survive. Iran’s balance sheet is
materially in the red, and for a long time. Brought to war despite their best
efforts to prevent it, and having lost a string of senior functionaries in the
war, survival as a country will be the biggest success they can attain. Each
drone or missile that flies out is only a desperate means to survive. Loss is
what they have. They have nothing to lose other than dignity.
Benefits?
The
world now sees Iran in a different light. It is the only country in the world
standing up to a bully, cost be damned. They have declared that they will stop
only when their conditions are met. So, if the war ends at their terms, it
will be a big political and economic victory. It will roll out the structure of a
new world order. That is possible only if Iran can wear out their adversaries.
America
A
Dream Gone Sour
The
dream of running over Iran, the last standing obstacle to American supremacy in
the Middle East, in a few days to effect regime change, installing a power
structure that will dance to American tunes, has certainly not worked. At least
in the time frame they had calculated. The Iranian command and control
structure was decapitated on the first day. Whenever a new head is announced,
Israel goes headhunting.
Yet,
Iran continues to fight. Iranians say they fight not with the body but with
their souls. In military terms, the USA has demonstrated to the world that they
have mapped Iran, to the last inch, last man. Despite uncontested aerial
supremacy and the type of missiles and arsenals under command that rain fire,
and all the repeated assertions that the war has been won, a comprehensive
victory, convincing enough, still seems far away.
Anything
America thought was inimical was bombed to dust. That also included a school.
In these endless bombing runs, America also irrevocably obliterated the
relevance of the United Nations once and forever. They have thrown the
international code of conduct to the winds. It has also set a precedent, a
dangerous one, for others with the stomach for such violence.
Reinforcing
Failure
One of
the most common mistakes militaries across the world make is to reinforce
defeats. This comes from the inability and reluctance to accept the truth that
a plan has gone awry. Stepping back is considered a defeat. Therefore,
those in charge continue to commit combat resources even when returns are
dismal. It took a long time for America to realise it in Vietnam and in
Afghanistan. Iran may not be a different arena. Despite mounting losses and may be few unbelievable
ones, America, in all likelihood, could commit more naval and air resources to
this war. It will not be surprising to see American boots on the ground. Egged
on by Prime Minister Benhamin Nethanyhu, President Trump could do that too.
Results
be damned.
Geopolitical
Status
A
quick victory over Iran would have certainly cemented America's place in the
global geopolitical space. But the war in Iran seems to have done just the
opposite. If the USA aimed to weaken Iran, contain it militarily, and
politically, then it has not yet succeeded. The American military could be deadly,
but Iran has shown the world that American might can be suffered and contested.
The lessons of the Vietnam War have been refreshed.
America’s
inability to prevent a war and the consequences of the war it started have
eroded America’s status as the primary security guarantor for Gulf Countries.
The investment in security made by the kingdoms and sheikdoms has proved to be
ineffective. Would they seek other means to secure themselves? Can such a
possibility be ruled out? If it happens, that could be the beginning of
the end of the USA as a global power.
The
war has shaken up the relationship between the US and its allies. Spain has
condemned the war as a “serious mistake” and “a unilateral military action and
violation of international law.” It has not allowed the US forces to use
Spanish bases for the war. The UK, once the strongest and most
unquestioning supporter, Germany and France have also refused to join the war,
although they condemned retaliation by Iran. Never in history has the USA been
so isolated in its military quest as NATO stands fractured. Trump has called
them cowards! Europe, slighted by Trump, is seeking strategic autonomy. If all
that was not enough, President Trump has left no opportunity to ridicule the
heads of state visiting the US. US diplomacy seems to have thrown the book of
decency into the dustbin. The current war has accelerated the degradation
of American foreign policy.
The
USA has committed heavily to sustaining Ukraine against Russia. It is
embroiled in Venezuela and wants to walk into Cuba. The war in Iran has
severely dented the image of its Navy, if not the carrier fleet and the stealth
fighters. In a way, the weight and reach of the American military, spread all
over with its assets depleting, could diminish its efficacy in countering China and
Russia.
The
USA, under President Trump’s “America First " policy, decided to exit from
66 International organisations, conventions, and treaties. The attack on Iran
while negotiations were in progress confirmed that the USA can take unilateral
decisions in violation of all internationally accepted norms. The USA is
working hard, like never before in history, to undermine its own position.
Oil
Revenues
The
increase in crude oil prices can help the American oil producers and companies
operating in the Gulf make a killing, provided they can take it out of that
place. Iran has threatened to target these assets located anywhere in the
Middle East. The US, however, has a huge reservoir of shale gas, which it has
been exporting as LNG to Europe and Asia. GAIL(India) is a major buyer of
US shale gas. Uncertainty in Gulf crude supply could help the USA earn higher
revenues for its shale gas. They could leverage it as a strategic asset in
geopolitical bargains.
Petro
Dollar
The
petro dollar could remain in place for some time, but the probability of an
alternative mechanism emerging soon cannot be ruled out. Unfortunately for
America, more and more countries might be forced to think beyond the dollar and
in the Gulf region beyond the petrodollar. The Yuan, Ruble, and Euros could
gradually replace the dollar.
There
are enough indicators to show that China would settle oil trade in Yuan. Iran
had already made a statement that containers settling purchase in Yuan will be
given free passage through the Hormuz. These are early days. A bilateral currency
agreement with trade surpluses adjusted in a third currency cannot be ruled
out. The dollar, in an unpredictably temperamental pair of hands, is no longer
the most trusted currency. If the excursion to cement the global
leadership position does not yield results soon, it could effectively weaken
the dollar and even lead to petrodollar atrophy. If that happens, it could
spell disaster for the American economy. However, expect the USA to do
everything possible to extend the relevance and inevitability of the dollar in
global financial systems. That could trigger many a confrontation in future.
Arms
Sales
The US
arms industry will certainly stand to gain. With shelves emptied out of
munitions meeting the expiry dates, there will certainly be demand for more.
Moreover, a lot of their strategic reserves would have been consumed and need
to be restored. Replenishment means money for the industry. Companies like
Lockheed Martin, Raytheon Technologies, and Northrop Grumman can look forward
to hefty orders. Post-war refit of the fatigued fleet is another windfall
waiting in the wings for US firms.
The USA is looking at a mixed bag, post-war.
Israel
Seeding
Wars
Israel
has publicly stated that it is committed to eradicating its existential
threats. Its actions against Hamas in Gaza and Hezbollah in Lebanon are in line
with this aim. The military action, ruthless and relentless, continues to take
out individuals Israel considers vital to these organisations. Collateral
Damage is of no concern to them. However, these organisations have not yet been
eradicated. Of all the reasons that emerge and keep coming up, depending
on who says, to whom and where, one reason for the Iran war is that Iran stands
accused of funding and supporting Hamas, Hezbollah and Houthis, besides plotting
to attack the USA and hoarding nuclear assets.
If we
see the progress of the war as of this date, decimation of Iran as a country
and eradication of the organisations Israel considers a threat will take much
more time than what Israel had initially calculated.
If the
Iran war goes in favour of Israel, in a short time frame, the likelihood of
another country or organisation in the region being labelled as the new
existential threat by Israel cannot be ruled out. With America playing host to
Israel’s demands, creating a new enemy is not difficult.
There
is also a school of thought that believes that all Israeli policies and actions
are driven by its desire to become the sole regional power in the Middle East
and thereby exercising control over the world economy. There is nothing to
suggest to the contrary. Internationally, most countries have started
distancing themselves from Israel’s policies.
Elusive
Peace
Israel
might degrade Iran’s military capabilities, but that will eventually be built
back with even more fierce asymmetry built in. Israel’s existential threat will
continue for as long as we can see. Extrapolating the current flow of events
and positions taken by various parties, peace seems to be an elusive
destination for Israel. A war can delay the next war, but cannot win peace.
Bonanza
Over the Horizon
The
rate of expenditure of munitions in war is far greater than the rate at which
they are manufactured and replenished. Iran’s dime-a-dozen drones and a few
missiles have elicited a price from Israel. The ultra-costly anti-missile
systems have been at work for some time and are fast depleting in stock. More
and more Iranian missiles, even if fired in fewer numbers than before at a
time, could get past the fail-safe Iron Dome.
With
news going out of Israel heavily censored, nobody knows the extent of
infrastructure damage within Israel. But it is a fair guess that Israel has
suffered considerable infrastructure damage. Rebuilding Israel will be costly.
The capital will have to come from Israel itself unless America decides to
underwrite the losses or forces the GCC to cough up the moolah. Irrespective of
who pays, those involved in rebuilding can look forward to making gains. Recouping
the arsenal will be another major economic activity.
Surge
in Orderbooks
The
defence industry in Israel will stand to gain during and after the war,
and so will those involved in rebuilding. Although the Iron Dome is no longer
an impenetrable defence, it may still retain its commercial value. It is
believed that the order books have found a surge with demand for an integrated
system comprising the Iron Dome, Arrow and David’s Sling. The War provided
Israel a chance for a live demonstration.
I do
not foresee any change in Israel’s policies for some time. Therefore, despite
whatever they may gain militarily, the balance sheet shall be negative in terms
of peace. If the absence of peace is politically more rewarding than
peace, isn’t war more beneficial?
The
Gulf Region
No
country in the Middle East has any profits to book in this war. Individually, it
is a loss; collectively, it is a loss, and losses are compounding on a daily basis.
Yet, it is intriguing to see how the war is shaping up.
The
USA and Israel have used both land and air space belonging to these countries
to attack Iran. Iran retaliated by attacking American military bases and destroying
most of the radar systems located in the Gulf region. In the process, many Iranian
missiles were knocked out of the sky, but the debris had to fall down. And that
set fire here and there. The host countries did not like it.
The US
attacked an Iranian bank and destroyed it. Iran called American commercial
interests in the region legitimate targets and launched their missiles. Many of
them were knocked out, but some found their targets. All countries hosting US
interests will continue to receive missiles at different intervals and with
different payloads. Dubai seems to be the most favoured destination for these
Iranian payloads.
Israel
bombed Iran’s South Pars gas field on 18 March 2026. It is one of the largest
in the world and supplies 80% of Iran's domestic needs. President Trump
categorically stated that the USA has nothing to do with it, but no one
believes it. Iran struck back on 19 Mar 2026, setting the Ras Laffan LNG
complex on fire. This facility incidentally services 20% of the world's LNG
requirements.
Iran also hit the Mina Al-Ahamadi refinery and the Mina Abdullah refinery in Kuwait. Iran also targeted the Habshan gas facility and the Bab oil field of the UAE. While it may serve Israel’s purposes to get the Arabs and Iranians to fight amongst themselves, oil prices are likely to shoot up. It has already crossed $110 a barrel. Where it is headed is anybody’s guess.
Iran’s
foreign minister had claimed that the USA hit a desalination plant in Qeshm
Island. There was also a report of a desalination plant in Bahrain being hit.
Iran denied hitting it. However, destruction of desalination facilities, in a
tit for tat, in the region cannot be ruled out. If it happens, it can wreak
havoc in the region.
The
water war can have unseen consequences, especially for India.
Security
Investments
Most
countries in the region had outsourced their security to the US and paid up for
the service. Now, they find themselves targeted for hosting the very same
facilities purported to be safeguarding them. In terms of investment, it turns
out to be a bad investment, at least for now.
Suddenly,
the countries in the region have to come to terms with the fact that the
security guarantor they had engaged not only failed to provide any security, but
on the other hand, the security guarantor itself had initiated the security
breach. Who will pay for the missiles fired? Who will pay for replenishing the
stocks? If the Gulf countries pay up, which eventually they will be forced to, the
US would have earned a profit too.
These
countries would also be dealing with a difficult question. Should they allow
the US to rebuild their military bases in their countries to continue with the
security umbrella? Obviously, rebuilding the billion-dollar early
warning systems that existed before 28 February will be far more elaborate and
therefore will be far costlier than before. Losses apart, a huge expense awaits
them.
Any
option?
If,
for some strange reason, can they decide to ask the USA to leave? Will the USA leave
just because they are asked to? For the Sheikhs and Kings, is it a Hobson's
choice?
Will
the Arab Brotherhood bury its hatchet and come together?
Will
the USA allow that? Will Israel allow the USA to permit it to happen?
Are we
looking at a new power structure developing in the region? These are
interesting questions with deadly answers.
Oil Revenues
The
masters of the vast oil reserves of the Gulf certainly have not benefited, at
least in the short term. Higher oil prices do mean higher revenues, unless
sufficient quantity can be shipped out. No one in the Middle East stands to
benefit, at least till the war ends. Loss of revenue, despite price rise, is
what is immediately seen on the cards. Destruction of oil wells and gas fields
has commenced in earnest, and this will have a catastrophic impact, both
short-term and long-term, on the oil-producing countries.
President Trump has called for navies from across the globe to keep the strait open. He has even requested China and Japan. Will they oblige?
China
- Myth versus Reality
Myth
One
set of strategic experts believes that the war would impact China more than any
other country. They even go to the extent of saying this is the American means
to checkmate China's growing influence in the region. In the initial phases, I also
thought it could be the primary byproduct. Maybe it was. There are reasons,
too.
The
economic engine of China is driven by the oil imports from the Gulf region.
China is the world's largest crude oil importer, and is said to import about 10
to 11 million barrels per day from various sources. Almost 50% of this (that
is, 5 to 5.5 million barrels per day) comes from the Middle East. China imports
from Saudi Arabia, Iraq, Kuwait, Iran and LNG from Qatar. About 45 to 50%
of China’s crude imports come through the Strait of Hormuz. China is the
largest recipient of Hormuz oil flows, and accounts for about 37.7% of all oil
passing through the strait. Choking Hormuz is like degrading China’s industrial
activities. It is only fair to consider that the situation in the Gulf would
undermine China's economic activities.
But,
is it so straight and simple an equation?
Reality
China
is said to have approximately 900 million barrels stored as reserves. That is
about 90 days of total import and about 180 days equivalent of import from the
Gulf. China is not in shock. There is proof. It was confirmed that at least seven
Russian crude oil tankers originally bound for China were diverted to India.
While India may be ramping up purchases, under temporary sanction relaxations
granted by friend President Trump, China had to be willing to give up that
volume. Details of the transactions have not emerged. But it can safely be
assumed that the diversion came with a premium paid certainly to Russia and may
be to China, too. If China were in an oil shock, not one tanker would have
headed to India.
One
cannot expect China to be a silent spectator for long, waiting for the noose to
tighten. China significantly increased its import of Russian oil. Before the
Iran war, they were importing 1.8 million bpd. It is said that they have
doubled the quantum in March 2026. It is believed that they have locked in
future shipments from Russia. India’s loss in Russia has been to China’s gain.
Some
experts believe that the bombing of Kharg Island is a prelude to the US taking
control of the island and its operation, and thereby restricting crude to
China. This is not impossible, for nothing is impossible. How
practical it would be remains to be seen.
Balance
Sheet China
China
is likely to benefit from the Chaos in the Gulf and the loss of credibility the
US has inflicted on itself. China remains the biggest trading partner for
most countries in the Gulf and has remained visibly clear of politics while
quietly investing in infrastructure. All six GCC countries (Saudi Arabia, UAE,
Qatar, Kuwait, Oman, Bahrain) are either formal signatories or active partners
in the Belt and Road Initiative. Interestingly, China maintains a very close
relationship with all the Gulf Monarchies and also Iran. This places them in a
unique sweet spot. If a successful mediation to end the war happens, it could
come through China.
Post-war, too, China will continue to be the largest importer from the Gulf and therefore
remain the biggest money bag for the kingdoms in the Gulf. It is likely to garner
a huge chunk of the post-war rebuilding allocations. It is likely to exploit
the hara-kiri USA has committed. It will be interesting to watch how China
manoeuvres itself through this crisis.
Russia
No one
is clear about the extent of assistance Russia is providing Iran in this war.
But there is a belief that Russia is providing Iran with intelligence and even
hardware for the resistance. The downing of the stealth fighters is also
attributed to Russian assistance.
Russia
has been the single most beneficiary of the war, and the least of the costs.
The immediate benefit flows directly to Russia, which is now selling oil at a
premium to those who want it. External pressure on Russia in the war
against Ukraine has also weakened. Nobody, not even Trump, is talking of Ukraine
and its need to be delivered from Russian clutches. It is a situation given on
the plate to Russia.
India
India
has a different set of matrices to handle. Let that remain for the next
article.
The
Story
Characters
in the story have no resemblance to any individual or any entity.
There
is an idiom in Malayalam, “ xxxxx Pidicaha Pulivalu.” It means, “Like the xxxx
who caught the tiger’s tail”.
There
is a story behind it, and the characters are known by their caste. Since
anybody can take offence at anything nowadays, I take the liberty of modifying
the names in the story, but not anything else.
Once
upon a time, there was a rich and smart man who was travelling from one place
to another and had to pass through a jungle. In those days, people walked from
place to place. The man had gold coins with him, which he kept in the fold of
his dhoti.
Somewhere
in the middle of the jungle, there was a big tree. There was a cunning tiger in
the jungle. He knew this was the route taken by travellers. It was the place he
could get an easy meal. That day, he was
hungry and came and pretended to sleep under the tree.
When the
man reached near the tree, he saw the tiger sleeping under it. The tiger jumped
and tried to catch our hero. Our hero dodged and ran around the tree
because he knew that the tiger would easily outrun him. The tiger started
chasing the man around the tree. They ran after each other: the man in front, and the tiger behind.
Suddenly, our hero had an idea.
At the
most opportune moment, he caught the tiger's tail. Now he could control the
speed of the tiger, and they continued going around the tree. Unfortunately, in
this melee, our hero's dhoti became loose, and the gold coins started falling
to the ground one by one.
Now
our hero could not let the tiger go, and the tiger would not let the hero go.
The gold coins were all strewn around.
It was
at this time that another traveller came to that place. He was surprised to see
a man running after the tiger with the tail in his hand. The man asked
our hero, “What are you doing?”
“Can't
you see? You pull the tiger’s tail hard, and it will poop gold,” He
replied.
Greed
hath no creed. “Can you please give me a chance?” begged the man.
“Sure.
Why not? I have got as much as I wanted. Now you can take my place. After all,
we are all human beings, and it is my honour to help you,” said our hero.
Soon,
the tiger's tail was handed over to the eager man. Our hero retrieved whatever
he could and fled for his life.
It
took some time for the man to realise that the tiger does not poop gold anymore.
The
story could have had only one ending.
It has
nothing to do with the war in Iran
Excellent! as always.
ReplyDeleteThank you very much
DeleteThe stick of all seven oil companies based in USA has seen quantum jump since start of this war. I think all parties are hoping for a divine intervention to let go of the tiger tale amicably 😃well analysed article
ReplyDeleteA well researched and a very interesting article about the US-Israel war against Iran.
ReplyDeleteHowever the analysis seems to portray Iran primarily as a reactive actor and US-Israel as aggressors. Iran is presented as a ‘victim’ in this conflict, ignoring the role it has played in promoting terrorism by supporting proxy groups across the Middle East.
The author was wrong in his assumption that the US bombed the girl’s school in Iran with a motive. It was not. It was an error of judgement and not an error of intent.
As rightly brought out by the author, the war is not going to end as per Iran’s terms. The US may partially lift sanctions, may guarantee against future attacks with certain pre-conditions but will never pay reparation of damages.
Enjoyed reading the article.
The War of Stupidity beautifully explained . As usual you have covered all aspects with facts and figures . A beautiful reading .
ReplyDeleteWell done Sir , keep it up
It is very well researched article. Various perspectives and nuanced derivativations are logical and crisp. As always.
ReplyDeleteI also feel that there are directives of war which we are in the dark. To be fsir the Israelis and US had attempted peace through the early 2020s. In the whole of the West Asia the team has been quite not at whole fault. They must have an end state clear in their mind and surely that is destruction of Irans capabiloty to an abysmal depth. After all the US and Israel have enriched from since history.
To be, or Not to be, remains the elusive question.
So well researched and narrated,as always.
ReplyDeleteWith a Mallu folktale to boot