Saturday 19 October 2019

AMBULANCES – SHOULD IT RUN AMOK?


Outrunning Death

Sirens wailing, lights flashing, ambulances zip through traffic as if nothing else exists in their way. Mortals admire his ability to turn traffic chaotic and even negotiate through it. It seems that his heroics alone, in carting the afflicted to hospitals at lighting speeds, is enough to prevent ‘the end’ and ensure survival of the patient. To us the public, he our saviour can outrun death.

What happens in the hospital at the emergency room or casualty is something different. Lightning speeds and driver’s daredevilry notwithstanding, the patient becomes one amongst many medical emergencies and receives a very informed and calibrated response, often mistaken by the near and dear ones as heartless apathy and callous complacency.  

Hailing Ambulances

Ambulances are used to evacuate accident victims or patients in emergency. It is common belief that, if a patient is ‘somehow’ ferried to the intended hospital fastest, survival and recovery stand better chances.  Thus, it has become a norm for drivers to fly ambulances over omnipresent potholes, ricocheting over unmarked humps on a ‘surface’ called road, chock-a-block with unyielding traffic and unruly people poised to strike at the slightest provocation. Knowing how emergencies are managed in hospitals, it is time to consider the need for ambulances needlessly rocketing all over.

Evacuation Woes

The maximum damage inflicted upon a victim after an accident happens during extrication from the wreckage. Unfortunately, the first respondents are inevitably people who have no clue of handling trauma. While many happily film the event, others shamelessly slip away. The few who dare, in their exuberance to extricate, drag the victim out holding whichever limb or part thereof they can first reach. In most cases rescuers, ignorant of the injury already suffered by the victim, unintentionally aggravate the condition. The victim’s ordeal doesn’t end there. Whatever damage is left to be inflicted or can be inflicted occurs during the reckless ride to the hospital.

Other medical emergencies are no different.

Imagine the state of a patient being evacuated in a medical emergency involving heart attack or asphyxia.  The speed with which an ambulance covers crowded and winding roads negotiating heavy traffic worsens the patient’s condition.

Mistakenly, speed seems to be the ultimate response.

Speed or Care?

Speed seems to be necessitated because it is important to provide medical attention without loss of time. Ambulances without requisite medical expertise on board resort to speed. If the requisite quality of medical care can be provided on board the ambulance, speed becomes inconsequential. An ambulance should ideally be moving the fastest to reach a victim or patient. Having reached the patient, its movement to hospital must be deliberate and with medical attention on board. Ambulance must have trained doctor or paramedics, adequately equipped to manage such emergencies. Ambulances should transform from merely being carriages to mobile intensive care units capable of providing medical support to stabilise the patient so that required medical interventions can happen immediately on arrival.

Timely medical support is of essence, not speed.

Role of First Respondents

Modern automobiles provide high degree of survivability and protection to occupants if safety instructions, like fastened seat belts or well secured helmet, are adhered to. With most of the impact absorbed by inbuilt crumble zones, many occupants escape from crashes with minor injuries. However, with the scant regard we have for safety norms, most individuals involved in accidents sustain grievous injuries. In such cases people who arrive first at the site become rescuers. Unaware of how crash victims should be rescued and prepared for evacuation, first respondents in their eagerness unwittingly aggravate injuries causing irrevocable damage to the victims. This can be avoided.

Enablers

NGOs, governmental bodies and organisations involved in social work must launch awareness programs to educate people on how to respond to medical emergencies and accidents. Various audio visual and print mediums of mass communication, including social media tools and street meetings must be employed to prepare the society to handle emergencies individually and collectively.  Simultaneously, ambulance services be mandated to upgrade on-board capabilities. Government must create a medical emergency response grid and all hospitals must be mandated to be part of the grid.



21 comments:

  1. Yes. Maximum care can be given by upgrading ambulances. Our roads are congested and often blocked. Correct and New initiative is to be taken by the authorities.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. i suppose we ned to think as a society what we want and how we want it

      Delete
  2. I completely agree with the problems pointed out.
    Not only good roads and better equipped ambulance are required but awareness among people in general to react in a sensitive manner is very important.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. educated and aware yet insensitive ! that's where the problem lies

      Delete
  3. Ambulances are those life saving mechanisms that ferry people to get medical attention at the fastest and best way, supposedly. Why I say, "Supposedly", is because most often it dose not happen that way. The insensitive nature of people especially in India has proved more often than not how human life can be treated so callously. People don't make way to Ambulancs no matter how loud the sirens blare.
    So creating awareness is not just the Government's responsibility, people should realise it could be one among us in that Ambulance someday and treat it with some empathy and sensitivity.
    While human lives are precious for all obvious reasons Human Sensitivity and Compassion needs to be inculcated along with some basic live saving training.
    Again a beautiful and thought provoking article.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. But there's a catch!
      on many occasions drivers of ambulances were caught doing errands and even couriering with lights and sirens at full go!
      Thank you for the detailed comments

      Delete
  4. A very superb and we'll thought out observation. U have hit the nail rt where it matters. It's timely medical care which matters not the speed of the ambulance.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you very much. we often miss the point in our pursuit of visibility. Medical care at the earliest is the essence, but slowly its becoming dumping at the earliest. after all society find that the caring hardworked doctors can be blamed more easily than the driver who aggravated the injury through his james bond style drive

      Delete
  5. Very valuable & variety life saving idea. It is late time to update our social & medical awareness like this. Transforming ambulances into mobile icu is a very innovative but very easy to impement if health dept cosiders this.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Sir,A very well researched presentation delivered in your classic style.Superb articulation indeed.I wish to echo the views of all others by stating the obvious that the subject deserves utmost attention but gets the least, Perhaps we have been trained to value life only to that extent.I strongly recommend that basic paramedic functions should be a graded subject in all our education curriculum.Following westerners we don't miss out on teaching the Xth grade internal parts of heart and lungs but not teaching them on essential paramedic functions which he or she has to undertake during emergencies.I compliment you for having brought forth such a vital issue so lucidly.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. thank you for the progressive and far reaching suggest.

      Delete
  7. A good initiative by Major General which other NGO's to continue.
    What happens in the hospital on arriving at lighting speed..... notwithstanding... ..very much true.
    Another important thing is whether all these ambulances are flying with patients?..that also to be checked.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you very much sir.
      you raised a question of concern! are all these ambulances really carrying patients??

      Delete
  8. While many happily film the event, others shamelessly slip away

    Got stuck for a moment on this point

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That's what society has been reduced to, onlookers, getaways or willing perpetrators
      Thank you

      Delete
  9. As usual very well written.
    You stole a march over me on this, I have been meaning to write a blog on this subject too.
    My wife and I are frequent travellers in and around the country and have observed emergency vehicles on our roads.
    Over the years our travels and stay in Kerala too have increased. One aspect of life that draws our attention very often is the speeding ambulances that crisscross the roads of the sate 24x7. Reckless driving, incessantly wailing sirens ,flashing head lights and cutting traffic signals on the most heavily trafficked and congested roads is the order of the day in the state. Much of the glitz and glamour that is exhibited by the providers of ambulance services may not really be called for in Kerala particularly since it seems to be one of the rare states where emergency vehicles particularly fire and ambulances get the right of way almost always. These seem to be more of sales and publicity gimmicks, after all these are not free services and the more the perks, the greater the cost,
    The speed at which these ambulances traverse the roads is frightening even for the most battle hardened soldier. I often wonder if there is a doctor or a paramedic on board the ambulance, which going by the speed at which it is travelling would certainly have a very seriously sick person on board.
    another question that haunts me is whether there is really a patient on board or is the driver taking the word for a ride since he gets the right of way.
    This brings me to the point that you bring out. What is required is adequate care on board an ambulance which does not come with speed and reckless driving.
    There has to be a specialised body that regulates these services and set down safety and service norms and these have to be enforced.
    The million dollar question is will that ever happy or if it does happen will it just be like the many regulators and laws that we have in many such areas which when read leave no room for lapses but in everyday life on ground are non starters.
    Public action, awareness and pressure are what is called for. Hopefully that will happen some day.

    ReplyDelete
  10. what a sharp and strong one liner. thank you.

    ReplyDelete
  11. yes sir. hope is what society lives on.
    thank you for the beautiful write up

    ReplyDelete
  12. Agreed,that ambulances race past at break neck speed but then why not?If its carrying a patient,who requires urgent med help,it helps.....moreover without the siren,horns blaring and making a ruckus,our great Indian mindset doesnt permit,easy pathway for the ambulances....also most amusing is the sight to see,the vehicle convoy,which tries to hook onto the ambulance and speed away to glory,in that melee..

    ReplyDelete
  13. Our country had education system in place before the advent of the British. We had an elaborate, systematic primary education system in place. Every damn thing was in place till the British came. But the education system that was prevalent before the advent of the British was unsuitable for the British. Ethics was an integral part of the education system which existed prior to the arrival of the British. White man never wanted his subjects to behave ethically. They wanted educated clerks who could work for the company or the crown. So they introduced their system of education, devoid of ethics. We are proudly following their education system till date. That education system does not impart any ethical knowledge to children. How to be a good citizen, how to respect elders, how to protect environment, how to become a good member of a society and contribute positively for the betterment of society etc etc is something that is not part of education in our country. Following of traffic rules by Ambulances/rest of the vehicles and respect for human life is something which is not their on any Indian mind because of the education that he received as a student. So there is nothing to get surprised in case an ambulance driver runs amok on a busy road because no body since his/her childhood taught him/her that such behaviour is unethical.

    ReplyDelete

PLEASE FEEL FREE TO COMMENT