Monday, 4 May 2020

EDUCATION : A COVID CATALYSED REVIEW



 The Unimaginable

Storage facilities overflowing, tankers, big and small unable to unload, oil has no takers and trades in the negative. As people shut themselves in, nations count and miscount their dead, diplomacy thick with accusations and counter accusations, economies bleed, businesses flounder and livelihoods vanish, mankind stares at endless uncertainty. We have even learnt to meet and greet from behind the masks.Mankind is now engaged in a strange battle for survival.

Speculations aside, nobody knows for certain what lies ahead. But everyone agrees that in the wake of the pandemic comes unprecedented fiscal chaos, large scale lay-offs and unemployment. World wars and cold wars, put together, couldn’t shake mankind the way corona did. Not many of us could have ever imagined our lives like this. Life with corona will be the ‘new normal’.


Ides of March and The New Normal

The ‘new normal’, everyone speaks about and presupposes with certainty, is “cause and effect’ determined. No soothsayer[1] to caution, the ‘Ides of March’ changed everything for the world. We came face to face with Covid and covidian terror has permeated all walks of life. Besides affliction and death, the most hard hitting covidian manifestation is unemployment. Road to economic recovery will be slow. 

Though establishments may not repopulate employee rolls to pre-covid levels, widespread outsourcing of micro-projects to individuals could happenEntrepreneurial environment could bloom.The capable will grab and corner opportunities. 

Schooled to meet assembly line conformity and unable to adapt to the sudden shift, many will find themselves unemployed and unemployable. An education system that bulk-produced the ‘overqualified unemployable’ will soon saddle society with the jobless.

Nonlinear Minds

World over, the system of education , caters to demands of mass production. Traditional schooling conditions impressionable minds to think linearly. 


Over time, literacy has come to be known as knowledge and rating on parroted answers to oft repeated examination questions, abilities. Standard operating procedures assure expected outcomes. Experimentation and innovations unwelcome. Imaginative application could easily be reckoned as violation of entrenched methods and process. Deviations became risk laden and if unsuccessful, invited unbearable consequences.

Luckily for mankind, there were always unfettered nonlinear minds, that refused to be stifled by prescription syllabus and persevered to break the shackles of straight jacketed education. Information technology is the gift of such nonlinear minds. 

Nonlinear minds validate Moore’s law.  
Nonlinear minds set course for Future.

The Catalyst

What Covid did to Indian education nobody ever could.

Covid forced authorities to reconsider teaching methods. Children, irrespective of grades and classes, are now engaged with their teachers online. While online classes helped maintain teacher-taught contact, it inadvertently added an avoidable dimension to home-environment. Virtual schooling also denied children, ‘real’ opportunities to develop social skills, a double whammy further eroding throughput of an inefficient system

Though the current shift is incidental, cosmetic and temporary, Covid proved that the Indian education system can easily adapt to far-reaching changes if adequately stimulated. Bigger and better things are possible with the system. It took us Covid for the revelation.

Why Education?

Though evolving continuously, education has always been society-centric. The archaic education system is long overdue for reforms. Though, subject of research and intense debates, biases adding to ferocity, there can be no doubt on the fact that education must benefit the society at large. Irrespective of the time one lives in, society must pursue education as an activity to facilitate its survival and growth. Education therefore must focus on two basic aspects; ‘Value systems’ and ‘Capability building’.

Value Systems

Education must result in promoting peace, harmony, tolerance and ensure life with dignity. Value based education needs to be uniformly imparted and ingrained so as to build a just and humane society. Dignity of labour becomes ingrained.

Over time, what was once integral to the curriculum as ‘moral science’ vanished. When concern for fellow beings are not ingrained in children as an essential virtue, it eventually creates an indifferent intolerant society. Society stands to lose, short-term or long term.

Capability Building

The component meant to enable individuals and build capabilities should be imparted based on abilities and aptitude. This is where the current assembly line system, staring with kindergarten and unending even with post-graduation and doctorates grossly falls short, mostly with substandard products. Millions of over-qualified, unemployed and unemployable graduates bear testimony to the inadequacy of the current education system, one rendered meaningless by capitation and reservation-based admission.

Overqualified or Underemployed 

Possession of a minimum educational qualification is mandatory for securing a job. So, everybody strives to obtain whatever ‘degrees’ possible by whichever means possible. Since there is no upper limit of education stipulated for disqualification, it is not uncommon to find a postgraduate concierge or a clerk with doctorate. While no one can object to any one studying, as much as one wants, it should not be at the cost of the society. It is pertinent to understand that, for the society, creating an unemployable population or employing overqualified people is a negative investment. While basic education must be the fundamental right of every citizen, every citizen should not be forced to pursue higher education just for the sake of a job.

Competency Based Education

Since determining aptitude could easily become subjective and therefore prone to manipulation while being administered, primary and secondary level education must be made compulsory so that all members of the society can read, write and comprehend. Even today maximum number of jobs are such that it can easily and efficiently be done by those with secondary level education. Is there a need for an engineering graduate to man a machine or sell a policy? 

Denying eligibility to anyone with higher than required qualification to jobs will reduce pressure on avenues for higher education. Higher education must be competency-based because the society needs to invest in this category chart its way forward.  Curriculum at higher levels must also provide the flexibility of choice and timing to the one who pursues it, unlike the set piece combinations now in vogue.

Socio-political Compulsions

Political requirements would dictate differential treatment to those from underprivileged socio-economic backgrounds. To fulfill such socio-political requirements, individuals from disadvantaged backgrounds could be educated at state expenses provided, they meet all parameters of competence. As such making education free and compulsory up to secondary levels would take care of lot of issues.

The future

Covid has forced us to review our education system. It and revealed to us that we can bring about changes if required. If a virus can impact us so much, sky is the limit for collective human will.






[1] Soothsayer who warned Julius Caesar about the impending tragedy that would strike him on the ‘Ides of March’

25 comments:

  1. JIBIN K Jacob4 May 2020 at 16:39

    The provision of higher educationa based on competency would reduce the overqualified employees and thereby reducing government's education cost.
    Providing a flexible education schedule for higher education will boost the number of students who does part time jobs and it will also be a boost to our economy.

    ReplyDelete
  2. The study of nature and environment and sustainable development should be included in the curriculum, at all levels. We should also have skills and vocations taught to teens, with exit avenues through assured employment. We will then avoid the present lacuna of engineers becoming can drivers. Nobody with any communal and political leaning should be allowed to start educational institutions. That will save us from communalisation and politicization of education.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ramesh Babu, your proposal is lot of theory, unfortunately which is impractical,I feel.

      Delete
  3. Theoretically what's stated is true and needs to be enforced. But in a democratic set up like ours, it would be unthinkable to even think of enforcing such measures, what with a hyper active judiciary and vigilant opposition. Very much possible in totalitarian regimes like China or N Korea. But it is definitely food for thought for the govt.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you sir.
      Theory is what defines methods. Practice is what transcends theory. Hyper activism is good unless it is done to extend the reaches of authority. we have done so many good things in this country without forcing it upon people. that i suppose is efficient administration. One step ahead, i suppose that is silent revolution.
      Wasn't Amul one such?
      Thank you very much for the thought provoking response

      Delete
  4. Ramesh Krishnan4 May 2020 at 22:13

    Well articulated. Some pointers to society and the curriculum makers. Compliments.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Pointers were always there. But remain unnoticed!!!
      Thank you very much sir

      Delete
  5. A well articulated and well expressed article my compliments

    ReplyDelete
  6. Sir, Education is complete, when social value is added to it.Hence classrooms remain the bedrock of education system.In India,basic education is provided to all upto +2 level with out imparting any professional knowledge.There after most people go for higher education purely to get a higher degree not related to a person's aptitude, ability,ambition or affordability.Unless a student is diverted to a education system most suitable to him after 10th class ,we will remain where we are now.Most of the teaching staff in India are not selected based on merit but on other considerations.They are neither good communicators nor motivators .They work to meet bothends pushing the students to depend on coaching classes.Unless there are fundamental changes in education system,Corona or ,no corona we will remain where àre we now.Zoom based education system is ok for professionals ,not for basic education.A thought provoking article , will someone matter takes note of it.thank you sir.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I true that. The article was meant to highlight the need for a comprehensive overhaul.
      Thank you

      Delete
  7. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Classes taking place online... that's the only change that the virus has brought about. But this is worse than what the classroom experience. Yes I meant the classroom experience is "bad", online is worse. If only teaching could be evolution centric and not knowledge centric. Students need to understand why they are taught and not what they are taught. The difference lies in a student's ability to grasp the application of the knowledge gained. Every brain is wired differently. A student of science doesn't have a brain superior to that of a student of arts. Education should be able to open up possibilities and not shut options.
    Post covid, I hope there is some change.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Good Evening Sir, Congratulations to the best efforts to bring out the problems being faced by the society in the present scenario with its remedical measures and achievements. Sir thanks a lot.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Needless to say, very well thought over and well written. Yes, education systems need to change but it seems to be a distant dream in India primarily because it has become so commercial at all levels of education.Education today is a business and a money spinner at that. Added to all this also the new model of franchise, whereby the institution offering a franchise, makes there money upfront and then leave it to the franchisee to squeeze money out of his CUSTOMERS under whatever pretext it be at the fastest pace.
    Gone are the days when the missionaries came in and set up schools which took in children of any caste or creed and imparted top class education. Moral science that laid the foundation of life for most of us is a story of the past.We are now in the age of air conditioned class rooms and five start facilities. No one really ask what they teach. One hears of every conceivable term starting from robotics to space science and astronomy, with study tours to NASA and tie up with many unheard of universities and school across the globe. They even buy the names of some teachers who have important sounding qualifications and also some well known big wigs in the field of education for advertisement and canvassing business
    Will all this change with online education? I have my doubt. If it does it will take ages ,but then the lobby that runs education at least in India will not let that happen.
    The sudden change to online education that we see now thanks to "COVID "is once again a style statement and some cover up that is being done to ensure that parents are kept happy and collection of fees is justified.The schools can thus continue to fleece parents, maybe also add an extra head now for online education.
    Many of the earlier responses have brought out very pertinent issues including the major problem of people being over qualified.
    Hopefully all this will change ,only time will tell.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The curse that we brought upon ourselves was commercialising education. when education became business, its prime cause of existence is profit not society's well being. that is the difference. we as a people lost it.
      everything has a life span. even this.
      someday we will realise our folly and we shall return.
      till then
      we shall strive and endure
      and
      we shall overcome

      Delete
  11. Col SK MANNIL (Retd)8 May 2020 at 21:03

    The COVID-19 Pandemic is definitely set to change world sooner or later. The way our Government Institutions, organizations and people think and functions will radically change. Perhaps for a new long term. Technology will become the biggest intermediary.
    of teaching - learning process. Higher Education will stand disaggregated and faculty and students are grapping with sudden new norm of completely tech mediated teaching and learning. Online learning is about one pedagogical model but an aggregation of various models. As it is indeed a specialised learning science that combines learning psychology behavioural analytics, content delivery and assessments to gauge and measure individual learning journey and progress. Sir, a very well thought out written topic which has become need of the hour and for post COVID 19 era.

    ReplyDelete
  12. History is witness to catastrophies chaos and recoveries .How we resurrect ourselves is a choice we make as a society . Consequences are mere end products of our choices on which we have no control.
    Let's hope someone powerful enough takes note adequately enough and is inspired enough.
    Thank you very much for the detailed comments
    Response from informed readers make articles meaningful.

    ReplyDelete
  13. This article definitely is an eye opener and and so relevant now. Unprecedented challenges which has exposed humanity to situations which nned to be addressed with balance and sense. Beautifully articulated by you, especially the education part and values. Kudos!

    ReplyDelete
  14. The entire education system should be reformed.This generation is only craving for marks with rote learning and as a result lack practical knowledge.Human values should be the core subject of the curriculum.
    So well written.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I’m going to read this. I’ll be sure to come back. thanks for sharing. and also This article gives the light in which we can observe the reality. this is very nice one and gives indepth information. thanks for this nice article... N95 mask China

    ReplyDelete

PLEASE FEEL FREE TO COMMENT